What is a Canary Deployment?

A canary deployment is a software release strategy that allows for the gradual and controlled rollout of new features or software updates to a subset of users or servers. It is named after the practice of using canaries in coal mines to detect toxic gasses. In mines, if the canary dies, the miners know to flee the mine. In software releases, if there are many errors in the canary version, we know to rollback before more harm is done.

In a canary deployment, a small percentage of the production environment, often referred to as the "canary group," is selected to receive the new changes. This group may be  a representative sample of the overall user base or server fleet or based on specific criteria, such as geographic location or user characteristics.

The new version of the software is deployed to the canary group while the rest of the users or servers continue to use the previous version. This allows for testing the new changes in a real-world environment without impacting the entire user base or server fleet.

During the canary deployment, monitoring and metrics are used to closely observe the behavior and performance of the canary group. If any issues or anomalies are detected, the deployment can be rolled back or paused before affecting the majority of users or servers. This provides an additional layer of safety and reduces the risk of widespread disruptions.

Once the new version has been thoroughly tested and validated in the canary group, it can be gradually rolled out to the remaining users or servers. This process can be automated or manually controlled, depending on the organization's requirements and infrastructure.

What are the Benefits of a Canary Deployment?

Canary deployments offer several benefits that make it a popular strategy for software releases. Here are some of the key advantages:

Risk mitigation

‍Canary deployments allow for a controlled and gradual rollout of new features or updates. By limiting the exposure to a smaller subset of users or servers, any potential issues or bugs can be detected early on. This reduces the risk of widespread disruptions and provides an opportunity for quick remediation before impacting the majority of users. Critically, since the prior version is still active, immediate rollback is achieved by simply redirecting traffic. No deployment is required. 

Faster feedback loops

With canary deployments, organizations can gather valuable feedback from real-world usage of the new version. By monitoring the behavior and performance of the canary group, developers can quickly identify any issues or areas for improvement. This feedback loop enables iterative development and faster iterations, leading to more robust and reliable software.

Accelerated release velocity

‍As the risk of releasing new capabilities is reduced, organizations will become more comfortable releasing more often. With the safety net of canary deployments in place, teams find themselves releasing continuously.

Improved quality assurance

‍By deploying the new version to a smaller audience, organizations can conduct thorough testing in a production. This helps uncover any compatibility issues, performance bottlenecks, or other problems that may not have been identified during pre-production testing. The ability to validate the changes in a real-world scenario enhances the overall quality assurance process.

Seamless rollbacks

‍In case any issues or anomalies are detected in the canary group, Canary deployments enable easy rollbacks. By reverting back to the previous version, organizations can quickly address any problems without affecting the majority of users or servers. This ensures a seamless user experience and reduces the impact of potential failures.

Performance monitoring

‍Canary deployments provide an opportunity to closely monitor the performance of the new version in a real-world environment. By comparing metrics and monitoring key indicators, organizations can assess the impact of the changes on system performance, response times, and resource utilization. This data-driven approach helps optimize the software and infrastructure for better overall performance.

What are the Challenges of a Canary Deployment?

Canary Deployments, while beneficial in many ways, also come with their own set of challenges and downsides. These downsides should be considered and addressed to ensure a successful implementation of the deployment strategy.

One downside of Canary Deployments is the increased complexity of infrastructure. Implementing a canary deployment requires additional components such as load balancers, traffic routers, and monitoring systems. Managing and configuring these components can be complex, especially for organizations with limited resources or expertise in deployment strategies.

Another challenge is ensuring version compatibility. The new version of the application may introduce changes that are not backward compatible, leading to issues when interacting with existing components or data sources. Thorough testing and validation are crucial to identify and address compatibility issues before rolling out the new version to a wider audience.

Monitoring and observability can also be challenging during Canary Deployments. Setting up effective monitoring systems to track the performance and behavior of the canary instances can be complex, especially when dealing with distributed architectures and multiple versions of the application running simultaneously. Organizations need to invest in robust monitoring tools and establish clear metrics to track the health and performance of the canary instances.

Having a well-defined rollback strategy is another important consideration. Despite thorough testing, issues may still arise during a Canary Deployment. Having an automated rollback mechanism, proper backups, and a plan to handle data consistency across different versions is crucial to quickly revert back to the previous version in case of failures or unexpected behavior.

User experience can also be affected during Canary Deployments. Exposing a subset of users to the new version while others continue using the older version can result in inconsistent user experiences, especially if there are significant differences between the two versions. Organizations need to carefully manage user expectations and communicate any changes or limitations during the canary phase to avoid confusion or dissatisfaction among users.

Lastly, implementing a Canary Deployment requires modifications to the existing deployment pipeline. This includes setting up separate environments for canary testing, configuring traffic routing rules, and integrating with monitoring and rollback mechanisms. Managing these additional steps in the deployment pipeline can increase complexity and potentially introduce new points of failure.

‍

How do Canary Deployments Work?

To implement a Canary Deployment, organizations follow several key steps:

Initial setup: Before initiating a canary deployment, organizations need to set up the necessary infrastructure components. This includes configuring load balancers or traffic routers that can direct incoming requests to different versions of the application based on predefined rules. The infrastructure should also include monitoring systems to track the performance and behavior of the canary instances.

Canary group selection: A small subset of users or servers is selected to be part of the canary group. These users or servers will receive the new version of the application while the rest of the users continue using the older version. The selection criteria can vary depending on the organization's goals and requirements. It could be based on user demographics, geographical location, or specific user segments.

Gradual rollout: The new version of the application is deployed to the canary group in a controlled manner. Initially, only a small percentage of the users are routed to the canary group receives, while the majority still uses the older version. For example, intially only 1% of traffic is sent to canary, then 5%, then 25%. Only then do we rollout the change to the rest of the servers. This gradual rollout allows organizations to closely monitor the impact of the new version on a limited audience and identify, bugs, poor user outcomes,or performance bottlenecks.

Monitoring and observability: During the canary phase, organizations closely monitor the performance and behavior of the canary instances. This includes tracking metrics such as response time, error rates, and resource utilization. Monitoring tools and observability systems help identify any anomalies or regressions introduced by the new version. Ideally teams will also track business metrics such as conversion rates. If any issues are detected, organizations can take corrective actions or roll back to the previous version.

Feedback collection: Canary deployments provide an opportunity to gather feedback from the canary group users. Organizations can collect user feedback through surveys, feedback forms, or direct communication channels. This feedback helps in identifying usability issues, bugs, or feature improvements that can be addressed before rolling out the.